How Do I Prepare for an Employment Lawyer Consultation?

Why Preparation Determines What a Consultation Is Worth

An initial employment law consultation typically runs 30 to 60 minutes and — depending on the firm — is free, flat-fee, or billed at the lawyer's hourly rate. In that window the lawyer must understand your facts, spot the legal issues, check the deadlines, and give you a preliminary assessment. Clients who arrive with a one-page dated timeline, a folder of core documents, and a clear statement of their goal routinely leave with a realistic valuation and a plan; clients who arrive with a story and no papers leave with 'send me the documents and we'll talk again' — a second billable meeting to reach the same point.

Preparation matters more in employment law than in most fields because the deadlines are short and layered. In Canada, employment standards complaints, human rights applications, and civil claims each carry their own limitation periods — some measured in months. In the US, a discrimination charge generally must reach the EEOC within 180 or 300 days depending on the state, while contract and wage claims follow separate state clocks. The first job of any consultation is deadline triage, and the client who knows their key dates makes that triage possible.

How Employment Lawyers Charge — and Which Structure Fits Which Case

Employment lawyers in both Canada and the US use three main fee structures. Hourly billing suits ongoing advice, contract reviews, and matters where the work is unpredictable; rates vary widely by market and seniority, so always get a written estimate of total cost through settlement. Contingency fees — the lawyer takes a percentage of the recovery, commonly 25–40% — suit larger claims with real damages (significant severance disputes, discrimination and retaliation cases) where the client cannot fund litigation; the trade-off is that a straightforward claim may cost more on contingency than it would hourly. Flat fees have become common for defined tasks, especially severance-review-plus-demand-letter packages, which many firms now offer at a fixed price.

The right question in the consultation is not 'what do you charge?' but 'which structure would you choose in my position, and why?' A lawyer confident in the claim will often accept contingency; reluctance to do so is itself information about how they value your case. Also confirm the mechanics: who pays disbursements (filing fees, experts), whether the percentage changes if the case goes to trial, and — in Canadian litigation — how a costs award for or against you interacts with the fee.

Evaluating the Lawyer: Green Flags, Red Flags, and Second Opinions

Use the consultation to assess the lawyer as much as the case. Green flags: they ask about deadlines early, want to see documents rather than just hear the story, volunteer the weaknesses of your position alongside the strengths, explain fee options without being pushed, and can say how many similar matters they have handled recently and how those resolved. A lawyer who practises employment law as a core focus — not as a sideline — will know the current severance ranges, tribunal timelines, and settlement culture in your jurisdiction, which directly affects your outcome.

Red flags: guaranteed outcomes or a specific dollar promise at a first meeting, pressure to sign a retainer on the spot, vagueness about total cost, dismissing your questions about strategy, or an assessment that never mentions a single risk. On any significant claim, a second consultation with a different firm is money well spent — valuations and fee proposals for the identical facts can differ substantially, and the comparison sharpens your judgment about both the case and the counsel. Whatever you decide, get the retainer and fee agreement in writing before any substantive work begins.

Related: Employment Law Wizards · All Employment Law Wizards · Can I Be Fired Without Cause? · Do I Have a Wrongful Dismissal Claim? · All Legal Wizards · AI for Employment Law Firms